Kritische Anmerkungen zum Fundkomplex der sog. Himmelsscheibe von Nebra

Abstract

The „Nebra Sky Disk“ was reportedly discovered in 1999 as part of a hoard during an illegal excavation. In elaborate and long lasting investigations an attempt was made to verify both the reported site location and the affiliation of the objects independently from the information given by the finders. Yet, a critical examination of the published results by the authors does not allow the conclusion that the site investigated in a re-excavation is correct, nor that the ensemble itself fulfils the criteria of a closed find (hoard). On contrary, according to the excavation findings, the ensemble could not have been in situ at the site named. The scientific examination of the objects contradicts rather than confirms their belonging together. If the disk is considered – as required by these facts – as a single object, it cannot be integrated into the Early Bronze Age motif world. Instead, a chronological embedment into the first millennium BC seems most likely. On the basis of this overall assessment, all further conclusions and interpretations of the cultural context and the meaning of the Nebra disk that have been made so far will have to be subjected to a critical discussion.